Tuesday, February 19, 2008

Valentine's Day Challenge Project

Like many holidays we celebrate the time of the year were moved coincided with a pagan festival related to a Christian saint or celebration, Valentine’s Day is an example. Several legends exist about the beginnings of Valentine’s Day which involved the marrying of or letting a romantic interest know how you feel about them. A related festival from Roman and earlier was the Lupercalia festival which celebrated the she-wolf who suckled Romulus and Remus, the legendary founders of Rome, in the cave of Luperal on the Palatine.

The Lupercalia Festival developed into a time of promising fertility and easy childbirth. Another aspect of the festival was for the single women to place their name in the large urn. After all the names were placed, the single men of Rome would draw a name of a woman who would then be paired together for one year. The selection would often resulted in marriage. February 14th was degreed as Valentine’s Day by Pope Gelasius in 498 in honor of Saint Valentine who was martyred for marrying Roman soldiers secretly.

Several legends of who Saint Valentine was have survived to today. One legend has St. Valentine as a priest who married Roman soldiers against a degree from the Emperor Claudius II. Claudius II felt single soldiers would be better fighters than whose with families. Valentine went against the emperor’s degree married young lovers. Once Claudius found out about Valentine’s activities a warrant was issued. While awaiting execution two stories developed. The first was that Valentine fell in love with a jailers daughter which the day of his execution he sent a note and signed it “from your Valentine”. The second story tells how people would leave messages in the cracks in the wall for Valentine to read and he would offer prayers for them.

From both the Pagan Rome and Christian holidays a very basic human desire has continued to be addressed, that of finding a special person to share a life together with. It has developed for one day to allows those we care about to be told. Though the date of St. Valentine’s Day may have been moved to “Christianize” a pagan fertility festival the basic message and meaning has survived.

COMMENTARY:

I found the research for the Valentine’s Day Challenge to be generally easy. Wikipedia and the History Channel’s website were the two sources I used proved to be informative and agreed with most of the information presented as fact. One issue I did encounter was with the History Channel's website, the information was very basic and unlike Wikipedia the site did not provide a means to link with important terms and concepts.

From the readings for this week I approached the assignment with a degree of mistrust of the free websites. After reading through the articles from both of the sites I found the facts did match up with several stories I have heard over the years of St. Valentine’s Day origins. I chose these sites, based on a very technical search using Google searching “history of Valentine’s Day”. The History Channel and Wikipedia were the both one of the top returns. Once I selected both I tabbed between the pages to compare and contrast them.

Wikipedia provided the means to dig deeper into the Lupercalia Festival origins by clicking on the hyper link. I was able to get a more specific explanation of the festival. The History Channel site was simple a text page with no hype links of terms. Though for what I was basing the assignment on the History Channel page proved to be more helpful with linking the Lupercalia Festival to St. Valentine’s Day.

The challenge was interesting and has made me more aware of the potential downfalls of open edit sites. Sites such as Wikipedia and the History channel are good for a basis of research but should not comprise the majority of ones citations. All the “facts” should be double checked with online sites were peer reviews are the norm and that the individuals who present the research are traceable. Though the e-democratic ideal that is foundation of the Wiki movement is a good idea, unregulated information presented as facts with no tests is as dangerous in the virtual world as in the real one.

Monday, February 11, 2008

Reviewing the Arlington Historical Society’s Website of Arlington County, VA

Arlington County, Virginia’s non profit historical society, founded in 1956 to maintain the county’s long history from pre-colonial times through the present, maintains this website. By educating the public of their community's diverse past the society supports research, collection, preservation, discovery, restoration and dissemination of the local history of Arlington County, Virginia. The website’s main purpose is to introduce the public to these resources.

Usability
The site is user friendly with links clearly labeled to both internal and external sites, but is plagued with dead links that limit effectiveness. Once the links are clicked, you are taken to more detailed pages where information on whatever topic or subject is sought. Many of the links are to outside resources such as the Barcroft School and Civic League , one of the civic associations that are located throughout Arlington County. Other links include to the county library, which is a dead link; the main county website, also a dead link; and to the Fort Myer history site, which is a dead link also. Some of the links that are good include the Smithsonian Institute, White House, and Library of Congress to name a few.

Apart from the few dead links the usability of the Arlington Historical Society is generally good. The site is very informative about upcoming events of historical interest to all county residents. The site does a good job of mixing the local and national historical topics tying them in together.

Content
The content of the site is primarily text based. The site does however have photos of various buildings both which are currently standing and those not longer around. An examples of these include from the no longer around side the Barcroft community history to Ball-Sellers House which is still standing and open to the public. The site provides many links to other resources and points of historic interest located around the county such as Arlington National Cemetery Newseum, and the Drug Enforcement Agency Museum to name a few.

Scholarship
The educational value of the Arlington Historical Society is focused towards the general public, which fulfills one of the major purposes of the site. The articles online are generally of those individuals sharing basic knowledge and not in-depth analysis. Those the site does link to other more scholarly sites such as the Arlington County Library’s local history department. On the museum section a call for artifacts to add the collect is stated:

The Arlington Historical Society is looking for artifacts to expand their collection and current displays for their museum at the Hume School. If you have any of the items listed below and would care to donate them the museum will gladly acknowledge donors in their exhibits (and you may get a tax deduction as well!) This list does not include everything we need, just some of the items our curator especially desires! Some items may be listed in multiple categories. At the bottom of the list you’ll find a list of things we do not currently need. If you have something interesting that’s not listed, please contact us!

Presentation
The presentation of the historical society’s website is very basic feel is very no frills. The layout takes you where you want to go and allows the user to get back to the main page for more exploration.

Use of new media
The lack of any videos or interactive links leaves the user few options other than to look of the basic information then moving on.